Comparison

Mak vs Copilot vs Claude.

Which AI tool for which people-management job. Copilot and Claude are excellent all-rounders. Mak is built for the moments that can end up at the Fair Work Commission.

The short version. You don't have to pick one. Most organisations should run a general assistant and Mak side by side.

Side by side

FeatureMakMicrosoft CopilotClaude
What it isSpecialist AI that guides managers and HR through high-stakes people situations, grounded in AU and NZ law and your policiesAI assistant built into Microsoft 365General-purpose AI assistant from Anthropic
Built forAnything people-related, especially performance, conduct, termination, leave, psychosocial risk and grievancesEveryday productivity in Word, Outlook, Teams and ExcelWriting, analysis, research and complex reasoning
Where employment-law answers come fromA Mak-maintained library of AU (federal and state) and NZ legislation, searched and cited for every answerGeneral model knowledge, web search and your Microsoft 365 filesGeneral model knowledge, web search and any files you add
Uses your policiesYes. Uploaded once by an admin, then paired with the law in every answerOnly if it finds them in SharePoint or OneDriveOnly if someone uploads them to a chat or project
Names risks before advisingYes. Flags edge cases, like a mental-health disclosure during a PIP, and suggests HR reviewNo built-in HR risk logicNo built-in HR risk logic
HR oversightHR sees active matters by category, status and escalation, with an audit trailNone for people mattersNone for people matters
Escalation to HROne click notifies the assigned HR contactNoneNone
Manager privacyHR never sees transcripts, only categoriesStandard Microsoft 365 controlsStandard Claude workspace controls
Keeping law currentMak maintains the legislation libraryDepends on the model. Not grounded in legislationDepends on the model. Not grounded in legislation
Indicative costFrom A$30 per user per monthCopilot Chat free with M365. Copilot Business around A$35 per user per month on topTeam plan from US$20 per seat per month (annual, 5-seat minimum)

When to use which

  • Copilot to write emails, summarise Teams meetings and find files.
  • Claude for deep thinking on long or complex material: strategy papers, research, careful document review.
  • Mak the moment a people situation could carry legal, financial or wellbeing consequences. An escalating performance issue, a possible dismissal, a complaint, someone on leave. Whenever you need to know what the law and your policy require next, and HR needs to know it's happening.

Why a general assistant isn't enough for people risk

  1. It sounds right, but may not stand up. General AI gives confident answers that aren't tied to the specific Act, award or NZ obligation. Mak retrieves the legislation and cites it.
  2. It doesn't know your rules. Good process follows the law and your own policies. Mak uses both, every time.
  3. HR is in the dark. When a manager asks a general tool about a disciplinary issue, nobody in HR knows. Mak gives HR visibility without reading anyone's chat.
  4. There's no safety net. Mak gives managers a clear point to hand over to HR before things go wrong.

Better together

Copilot or Claude covers the roughly 80% of the workday that's general productivity. Mak covers the 20% that could end up in front of a tribunal.

Mak provides guidance and visibility, not legal advice. Managers and HR own every decision.

Add Mak to your toolkit.

Keep your general assistant. Give your managers a specialist for the people moments.