The short version. You don't have to pick one. Most organisations should run a general assistant and Mak side by side.
Side by side
| Feature | Mak | Microsoft Copilot | Claude |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Specialist AI that guides managers and HR through high-stakes people situations, grounded in AU and NZ law and your policies | AI assistant built into Microsoft 365 | General-purpose AI assistant from Anthropic |
| Built for | Anything people-related, especially performance, conduct, termination, leave, psychosocial risk and grievances | Everyday productivity in Word, Outlook, Teams and Excel | Writing, analysis, research and complex reasoning |
| Where employment-law answers come from | A Mak-maintained library of AU (federal and state) and NZ legislation, searched and cited for every answer | General model knowledge, web search and your Microsoft 365 files | General model knowledge, web search and any files you add |
| Uses your policies | Yes. Uploaded once by an admin, then paired with the law in every answer | Only if it finds them in SharePoint or OneDrive | Only if someone uploads them to a chat or project |
| Names risks before advising | Yes. Flags edge cases, like a mental-health disclosure during a PIP, and suggests HR review | No built-in HR risk logic | No built-in HR risk logic |
| HR oversight | HR sees active matters by category, status and escalation, with an audit trail | None for people matters | None for people matters |
| Escalation to HR | One click notifies the assigned HR contact | None | None |
| Manager privacy | HR never sees transcripts, only categories | Standard Microsoft 365 controls | Standard Claude workspace controls |
| Keeping law current | Mak maintains the legislation library | Depends on the model. Not grounded in legislation | Depends on the model. Not grounded in legislation |
| Indicative cost | From A$30 per user per month | Copilot Chat free with M365. Copilot Business around A$35 per user per month on top | Team plan from US$20 per seat per month (annual, 5-seat minimum) |
When to use which
- Copilot to write emails, summarise Teams meetings and find files.
- Claude for deep thinking on long or complex material: strategy papers, research, careful document review.
- Mak the moment a people situation could carry legal, financial or wellbeing consequences. An escalating performance issue, a possible dismissal, a complaint, someone on leave. Whenever you need to know what the law and your policy require next, and HR needs to know it's happening.
Why a general assistant isn't enough for people risk
- It sounds right, but may not stand up. General AI gives confident answers that aren't tied to the specific Act, award or NZ obligation. Mak retrieves the legislation and cites it.
- It doesn't know your rules. Good process follows the law and your own policies. Mak uses both, every time.
- HR is in the dark. When a manager asks a general tool about a disciplinary issue, nobody in HR knows. Mak gives HR visibility without reading anyone's chat.
- There's no safety net. Mak gives managers a clear point to hand over to HR before things go wrong.
Better together
Copilot or Claude covers the roughly 80% of the workday that's general productivity. Mak covers the 20% that could end up in front of a tribunal.
Mak provides guidance and visibility, not legal advice. Managers and HR own every decision.